Rate the signature and avatar above yours

[Shiryuu]

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

[DarkyNekoChan]

Siggies Only

Ponzu: What tha....? Amazing pic.... 10/10

NekoRyuKen: Meow...... =^^= maybe the font could be a little small... 9.3/10

[shinyo]

HAT - jezus you should stop doing that =P [roles his eyes] 10/10

Ponzu - she's got her finger striped with that hairband[?] ? cute 9,5/10

SolRyuKen - i think this sig's better than the old one, 9/10, it's a little bit meshed, maybe try a bigger resolution.

darkness_illusion - you finaly got a sig without empty space =] 8,5/10 As for me, I don't like the pastel drawing.

Heh, I like mine and i don't wanna change it, huh I'm emotionaly binded to it =D

[nick64]

Nick64 sigs only
1.) 9.75/10 - Sexy but not graphic, the only thing you could do is make it the same size as the other two for the lenght, 450p. Too much space between your nick and the girl, IMO
2.) 9.3/10 - Parts of the sig seem to be blurry/have some noise in it and the font for your nick gets to me, don't know why!
3.) 9.9/10 - Just the font gets to me here also!

suggestions noted!
personally i liked the first one but i will make that smaller.
As for Font, i can't seem to get the right fonts at all (thx for font site HAT), how come Photoshop doesn't let you preview the font style before applying it?

[Rai Kanegasi]

Look at mine. I've changed a few times due to look and mod problems.

[Surreal999]

I only rate sigs unless otherwise specified.

Sureal999 I love your Osaka army sig and VoA sig. It suits you very nicely. Wel done Your new Ah My Goddess sig is also very beautifull. I always liked the series alot. Making it must have cost alot of work.

Many thanks for for your compliments and insights! It's really not too much work, I use a lot of tutorials along with my basic knowledge of ps tricks and I will play around with the layers and other effects until I get it to my liking. Most of my sigs usually take a few hours or more to make, as I am no expert with ps.

S&T Kawaii Love: Cute sig! Good organisation of the K-chan pics. 9.0/10
Previous S&T sig: Ahh!!!...You changed this before I could rate it! It was very pretty and I really liked this one a lot. 9.9/10

HaT: 4 post #1859 Your sigs Just keep getting better all the time. I like your subtle use of ps techniques and the brilliant clarity of both sigs! 9.9/10 & 9.9/10

Xdeg: Not bad for a 16-bit sig. Interesting choice to go old-school in it's design for an old-school mahou bishoujo series. 8.0/10

SolRyuKen: That maybe a quick job but I still like it a lot! My only complaint is the noise visible on the left side. 9.5/10

Ponzu: Wow! Another great sig! I think that the filter (I cant remember the name) that you used goes quite well with the pic! 9.9/10

chief977: The grayscale border is an interesting effect, but I am not too fond of it being dithered. Otherwise, it is a great sig of Haruka! 9.5/10

nick64: Exp#1- 9.8/10, Exp#2- 8.5/10, Exp#3- 8.5/10 I really like the first one! However, the last two need to be cleaned up with layering, transparency and a blur to smooth out some of the noise.

chompy: That sig is heartwarmingly cute! Simple yet effective! 9.9/10

darkness_illusion: Wow! That sig is hot! :sizzle: I also like the border! 9.9/10

shinyo: Ponzu, you did a great job on shinyo's sig! 9.9/10

Rai Kanegasi: I am not a really biG fan Of Automated PC spec sigs so I will Rate your avatar. IMHO, the pimp hat is definitelY highspeed! Hooah! 9.5/10

Edit: 9.9/10 is the highest rating that I will ever give, even for those sigs that completely blow me away, because there is always room for improvement.

[nasman]

the one above looks very professional and shiiiny - 9/10!

i just knocked mine up from mspaint plus some crappy ulead effects because i was bored - dont be too mean!

[havariceball]

nick64 - I love the avatar. So pretty ^__^ and your sig is pretty plain and simple... 8/10 ((Im talking about the one just in your most recent post))

Rai - I like the avatar...cute and evil (its staring at me) and I have that buddy in my AIM profile

[Rai Kanegasi]

...

Rai Kanegasi: I am not a really biG fan Of Automated PC spec sigs so I will Rate your avatar. IMHO, the pimp hat is definitelY highspeed! Hooah! 9.5/10

...

Did you just give me an army subliminal message?!?! OMGWTF...army sux, it's all Navy for me (third line from the bottom of my J-Sig)

Oh, and your ava's pretty cute and your sig has that...flowy...feeling, like everything means something ( 9/10 )

[Vimana]

Been a while, but I've tried to improve my avatar and signature so I hope you all like.

I don't have that much of time now so I'll just try to rate the av and sig above this post.
Rai Kanegasi:
That avatar is quite cool in its own way, besides, sprites rock! 8/10
That sig though... It just seems a little too nerdy (be it a good or bad thing...) 5/10

[Rai Kanegasi]

Thx Vimana

Your avatar's not super ultra cool-lookin, but it's a really good choice and brings personality into view - 9/10
Your sig matches your avatar (which is very popular and looks better) and has a well done border and everything - 9.5/10