Rate the signature and avatar above yours

**Shiryuu** · 01-05-2005, 04:56 AM

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

**DarkyNekoChan** · 03-26-2005, 06:42 PM

Siggies Only:

Knifes: m....... probably it's my monitor resolution, but I can't see clearly the quote on your sig... (actually on 800x600)

*changes to 1024x768*
ohhh..... yep, it's my monitor

if I'd to make something ; i'd add a animated glow on the pic.... the rest is perfect...
(and what's the font??

) 9.9/10

SirenDestiny: Who is the gal in your siggie??

8.5/10

**Kitee** · 03-26-2005, 07:11 PM

Okay, for the text message under my signature, I changed their colors to blend in with my signature. ^^;

Knifes: A very good signature. I like the border where you cut out a small part to the corners. Also the outer border is thicker than the inner border. Quite unique. The quote is very deep. Took me some time to understand it. Is the last word "existence"? If it is, then you spelled it wrong.

The quote also served the purpose of covering up the empty space the foreground left behind. As for the image, it's a bit blurry. Try sharpening and contrasting a little. Overall, a well done signature.

**evilwhat** · 03-26-2005, 07:22 PM

HAT:
Nice use of purple shades for your sig. The girl is yummy! (mmm see-through gown) The only complaint I have is that it's another anime related sig (but then again it's HongFire Anime Network). Ah well still good.

Rating: 8.5/10

**pow155** · 03-26-2005, 07:52 PM

sig only:
Rai Kanegasi: i like how you did your border very nice. 8.9/10
HAT: another cute anime girl

very sharp image 9.5/10
SirenDestiny:good sig. 8/10
Knife: like your blizzard sig. goes with the pic well. nice 9.4/10
The Remedy: the eye is kind of scary. very nice sig 8.9/10
ponzu: very cute 9.5/10
nasman: 7.8/10
darkness: border looks very nice. 8.9/10
evilwhat: dancingbear. very nice. i like the video in your sig. and its less than 100Kb. very nice. 9/10

oh, i made this new sig, today. just reinstalled photoshop

**Glorfindel** · 03-26-2005, 09:01 PM

pow:
don't really have anything to say about the avatar except that i like the art style.
For the Signature the only thing that i don't like (personal thing) is the border. Not a
fan of it just seems to hurt the eyes (could just be me)

evilwhat:
nice all around. Just look at that bear dance, he shames my feeble attempts to dance

**Sphie** · 03-27-2005, 02:12 AM

Glorfindel :
Your avatar is pretty hard to see, a bit too dark if you ask me. 7.5/10.
I've got a new avatar, so I would like to see less people skipping me, thanks in advance

**pow155** · 03-27-2005, 02:23 AM

Originally Posted by Suzuran

Glorfindel :
Your avatar is pretty hard to see, a bit too dark if you ask me. 7.5/10.
I've got a new avatar, so I would like to see less people skipping me, thanks in advance

ok, i won't skip you. anyway the avatar is cute with a nice border around it. 8.8/10 for cute. i like your other ones better.

**nick64** · 03-27-2005, 08:23 AM

Might as well rate my new one (so far im trying to keep up a new sig/ava/wallpaper per 2 weeks.. i will upload Scrapped princess wallpaper later tonight if i can)

might i ask, how am i supposed to get rid of the white boarder round my ava? I want to make a perfect circle

**crucif-X** · 03-27-2005, 04:48 PM

Glorfindel: 9.5/10 - A very dark and creepy sig, and the graininess of the picture (whether intended or not) really heightens that effect. Nice quote!
Suzuran: 8.9/10 (avatar) - cute girl, but like pow155 said, I liked your previous avatars better. I think the girl in the pic would look even cuter if her hair was a little longer

pow155: 9.5/10 (new sig) - has the feel of a canvas painting, and the (what looks like a) vertical crack in the painting about 3/4 of the way from the left makes it look even more authentic. As for the border, while it does seem a bit unorthodox, looks okay to me

.
nick64: 8.9/10 (avatar) - 9.4/10 (sig) - Cute ava/sig combo. It seems you figured out how to get rid of the white border since I only see transparency around the circle. The green circular border still seems a bit rough on the outer edges which is why I didn't give it the 9/10 I would have liked to. Maybe try anti-aliasing or smoothing it out some. For the sig, I love the girl, very cute. Only real complaint is maybe the background color (though the background itself is simple and pleasant). Yellowish-orange just seems to be a little hard on my eyes. I'm okay with some yellow, but there's a lot of yellow here

. She might look just as good with another color thats easier on the eyes.

**nick64** · 03-27-2005, 04:57 PM

Thx for feedback, yeah i need to sort out green edges, i will do that tomorrow, but im quite tired atm.
As for sig, since my pc suffered some deleted/corrupted files lately, i can't get back my pic with the different layers.. so i couldn't resize it.

Im happy with the new sig i got now anyways,

Thx for feedback