Rate the signature and avatar above yours

[Shiryuu]

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

[crucif-X]

nick64: Wallpaper - I like the overall composition. The wide-screen look with the sky-blue top and bottom bars and the background picture in the center is interesting. Again, there are parts on the outer edge of the girl that could probably be smoothened/erased a little more (for example, her dress between the knees, there are some red/yellow colors on the edge that don't seem to blend well). But this is only a minor issue. Really nice wallpaper. My recommendations for improvement would maybe to knudge the girl a little higher to make it appear as if she were sitting on a windowsill (in this case the bottom blue bar). Also, maybe add a light stroke or outer glow to the fonts on the right side. "By Nicolas Wong" is kind of hard to read, maybe increase font size just slightly. Anyway, those are my thoughts, do what you will with them . Overall, very nice wallpaper!
Rai Kanegasi: Now I feel I can rate your sig . I like the colors, they really stand out. Who is the character in the pic, he's really pimping it out . The way you layed out the sig in thirds makes sense with the two guys on the outside with quote dead center. As for the addtional chatterbox pic, I think that it's best left out as I feel it doesn't add anything, but thats just me and you prolly have a reason for having it there. - 8/10.
jujufe: Avatar - 7.8/10. Interesting avatar. Looks like one of those Indonesian dancers/performers I learned about in my music class

[S&T Kawaii Love]

crucif-x: ava = 10/10 (wow)
sig = 10/10 (wow)

[PrinceKr85]

ooh ooh... i've been waiting to comment on S&T's avatar and sig... at least the ones i've been seeing ^^;

lets see.......

Avatar: i give it a....9.7 (^^)
i like the dual person (Sakura & Tomoyo-chan) avatar... it looks like a manga cell... maybe not....

Sig: 9.5
cute~

[Xdeg]

PrinceKr85
nice av.. really i like it very much. it has this.. "mhmmm" in it (if you wondering what is "mhmmm" .. i just make that noise when i see it and by that I mean it draws attention and its nice) 9/10

sig - ermmm lol.. good that ther is a note about the grainy effect xD i don't really see a purpos for this, coz it dosn't even look artistic but ok, lets say it was on purpous - 7/10 (it would've been 4/10 coz of the big pixels but ok ~_^ )

[eMKa]

PrinceKr85:Nice sig and avi combo 8/10 for both.
Xdeg:Sailormoon?For me avi is ok 8/10.but sig is to light and blurry 7/10.

[HdM]

mmmkl: sig rox. 10/10

ava is okay, but looks somehow strange o.o probably a bit too small? :S (i know there is a maximum of 80*80.. anyway.. *g*) 7/10

[nick64]

nick64: Wallpaper - I like the overall composition. The wide-screen look with the sky-blue top and bottom bars and the background picture in the center is interesting. Again, there are parts on the outer edge of the girl that could probably be smoothened/erased a little more (for example, her dress between the knees, there are some red/yellow colors on the edge that don't seem to blend well). But this is only a minor issue. Really nice wallpaper. My recommendations for improvement would maybe to knudge the girl a little higher to make it appear as if she were sitting on a windowsill (in this case the bottom blue bar). Also, maybe add a light stroke or outer glow to the fonts on the right side. "By Nicolas Wong" is kind of hard to read, maybe increase font size just slightly. Anyway, those are my thoughts, do what you will with them . Overall, very nice wallpaper!

oops, gave you the older version, yeah i did clean up the borders of the girls.

i will do somethign about my text on the right.. i got rid of the 'By Nicholas Wong' text (oops shouldn't use my real name dammit!) . Thx for feedback

[Kitee]

New avatar from me. ^^;

S&T Kawaii Love: Very manga feel. The colors are also very sharp. You might have edited the text, but I don't know. The quote is quite true and interesting. I agree where you just stuck with the black border. Overall, a simple signature, but it would've been worst if you made it look fancy. 8.4/10

mmmkl:I can see vertical lines coming down from the top. I don't know if that's intended or not. The top border color is different than the bottom border color which is quite unique as it follows the contrast of the signature. I also see a happy face on the right corner of the sig. I might be seeing things. The image is quite good, yuri style, but too much space has been left out. It is also a bit blurry.

[Tortured-x]

well i been fiddling around with the current sig and seing what else i could do to it.

[pow155]

jasperz87: i like your shadow reflection. looks good 9/10
oblisk10: too plain 7/10
Rai: nice sig, maybe change the text chatterbox. can't really read it. i had to concertate in order to read it.
jujufe: avatar: pretty good. 8/10
S&T Kawaii Love: the pic on the left looks nice. like manga drawing. really nice. 8.6/10
Xdeg: looks like she's under water. nice bubble effect. couldn't really see the word on the right. overall nice 8.7/10
mmmkl: lol, yuri. i love it. nice yuri pic. good quality 9/10
HdM: like your border. looks nice. 8/10
HAT: new avatar: better than your old one. 9.4/10
Tortured-x: there's nothing on the left side. the effect of the character doesn't really go well with the background even though the color matches. 8/10