Rate the signature and avatar above yours

**Shiryuu** · 01-05-2005, 04:56 AM

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

**chompy** · 10-24-2005, 12:04 PM

Noodlebox: orange is my favourite colour, but i dislike gigner hair...
the av and the sig have a home-made feel. did you draw them yourself?

Bruceko: Ownage av. the sig is wierd..

me: new av. the sig wasn't my creation, but i love it's minimalist design.

**Noodlebox** · 10-24-2005, 04:05 PM

Chompy: Haha I think it's very interesting. But it doesn't feel simple, don't know why. Like the mask of Bjork. How did she made the mask. Was it interwoven, carve, waxed or something else? The photography of how they use the lighting, the fan, hairstylist, if they photoshop-editing or if the photographer took a very perfect shot that hardly needs editing, you just don't know. It feels like a lot of work music video, photography, and design which is pretty interesting, a touch of modesty the image it has, I think. And that Free Mumina I like the "My pathers , My brothers." part. My signature and avatars? Yea I home-brew em. They're actually failed picture for the member's art gallery, well all of the image I posted are failed concepts but these are the ones that I like so stick em on as avatars and signature. I'll keep drawing and CGing, but whatever. Good show Chompy.

**Ether** · 10-24-2005, 04:37 PM

lol, chompy's sig looks like catwoman

noodlebox's av and sig r cool, brite colors and simple design, 8.5/10 for both

**orka** · 10-24-2005, 07:36 PM

Ether, I dunno what run-ra-ra is (I actually think she's humming), but that's a cute pic. Pretty simple, but I like what you did with the borders!

9/10

I'm currently avatar-less, and the sig is one of my first attempts at making a banner. I'm Photoshop-illeterate, mind you. @_@

**chompy** · 10-24-2005, 07:41 PM

ether: love the avatar. i've seen the sig button before...pretty tall

orka: if that is a first attempt, then kudos ^_^ it is very nice.

k...

i am just getting to know imageready. i made a sig, but i am not sure which one looks better, animated or not. please give your opinion.

**Noodlebox** · 10-24-2005, 07:48 PM

Get the animated one it's more catchier. How do you the imageready animated one?

**Ether** · 10-24-2005, 11:37 PM

lol chompy, i would go for the unanimated one

cuz the moving highlight kinda distracts the eye from the whole sig

**Noodlebox** · 10-24-2005, 11:44 PM

Originally Posted by Ether

lol chompy, i would go for the unanimated one

cuz the moving highlight kinda distracts the eye from the whole sig

What? Really? How?

**Lisa Hayes** · 10-24-2005, 11:56 PM

the looping animation of the text is still clear when it is starting and at the end.
it's either something you wanted, or something you forgotten.
I think it would look better if it is fixed.

@noodlebox
always appreciate something that is originally colored. compared from the last, the improvements are clear.
and no, i don't want to be your coloring-sensei ^^

**Kouji** · 10-25-2005, 01:16 AM

@lisa
AVA, nice effect of the Paper & the Girl on it With a cute Expression 8.5/10
SIG, Very nice i like the Text glow effect, just the Text is hard to see untill the light hits it 8.5/10

heres my Sig i want Rated