Rate the signature and avatar above yours

**Shiryuu** · 01-05-2005, 04:56 AM

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

**Shex** · 10-29-2005, 01:24 PM

love your sig but it blends way too well hard to read text. 8/10

I really don't rate avatars but okay 9/10

and I just relized the f****************************** image ready made my sig un-transparent like a faggot ....... and as for the open space a border can fix it

help me decide please make suggestions

DDDDD

**Azstraph** · 10-29-2005, 03:07 PM

Sig-Avatar:
ShinXero - 9/10 - 9.3/10 - Character a little blurry in some spots. Nice use with the flare.
dvx - 8.5/10 - 9.5/10 - Yeah need to work on the transparency on both. Maybe move your nick over to the left more, create space between the character and your nick.
xaero - Sig only - 10/10 - Big improvement! Nice effects and love the quote.
milkmandan - 9/10 - 9.5/10 - I'm not a fan of small sigs but good use the colors and easy to the eye text. What does that symbol mean?

--Rep points to whomever actually rates/comments on mine 1st!

**Hypersoup** · 10-29-2005, 03:35 PM

Haha, poor Azstraph; milkmandan didn't rate his avatar and sig

I guess I'll have the honours to do it then.

I think I've already commented on your avatar several times. I'll say it again... looks nice ^_^. Always liked chibi hisui pictures, they're always so cheerful. The signature is okay I guess. There's nothing I especially like about it but there's nothing I especially dislike about it either. Was it you that said that you vectored your sig? If so then you did a really good job tracing, looks very clean. And just out of curiousity, how are you posting on HF if your internet is down from Hurricane Wilma?

Hmm... on second thought, I think I will suggest something. I think you should've removed the hair reflections at the top for both the girl and the guy. Although it's just a nit-picky thing, it kinda throws off the whole signature. Plus there's a little dot at the end of the guy's chin that might look better coloured in

. (lol, like I said, there really isn't too much I don't like about it, everything I mentioned is just being picky.)

Back to doing BruceKo's sig now. Can't think of any more ideas... pretty drained at the moment. Not to mention I gotta finish my own set. By the way, like Azstraph, first person to comment on my ava and sig (or lack thereof XD) gets a rep. ^_- b

EDIT: Oh yah, score: Avatar: 8.5/10 / Sig: 8/10

**Shex** · 10-29-2005, 04:14 PM

Az : pretty good but you could use a little more graphics

8/10
Hyper: I LOVE YOUR SIG!!!!! OMG 0/10

**Azstraph** · 10-29-2005, 04:21 PM

Avatar-Sig:
Nothing to rate now.

THXs Hypersoup for the comment, REP points given

. Yeah I redid the picture and made it into a sig with changing the BG and adding a reddish tint to it. Also included my nick in it.

As to the Wilma thing finally got it back on Wednesday just forgot to update that statement

.

Original Vector - http://img363.imageshack.us/img363/7...ctors16390.jpg

**BruceKO** · 10-29-2005, 08:46 PM

har har har... I have one more club-button now

Somehow my sig starts to look messy now...
Any suggestions>

**tofuman80** · 10-29-2005, 10:32 PM

You know Bruce, it'll be really awesome if you can fit all that stuff into one single sig. With all these clubs, it looks awfully messy like you said; by organizing all of it into one single sig, not only will the whole thing have a cleaner feel to it, but it'll also show that no matter which club you're in, its still anime. ^_^

BTW: I prefer not to give any critiques for sigs that you yourself didn't create.

**orka** · 10-29-2005, 10:39 PM

Where did you guys get such skills?

Anyhow, my old sig got banned cus the file size was way too huge (yea I wasn't thinking lol). The one I got now is actually a avatar that I use for some other forums. Nothin' fancy since it has to be under 20kb... I should prolly stick with being simple for a while since I can't really do much anyway.

**BruceKO** · 10-29-2005, 10:52 PM

Originally Posted by tofuman80

You know Bruce, it'll be really awesome if you can fit all that stuff into one single sig. With all these clubs, it looks awfully messy like you said; by organizing all of it into one single sig, not only will the whole thing have a cleaner feel to it, but it'll also show that no matter which club you're in, its still anime. ^_^

BTW: I prefer not to give any critiques for sigs that you yourself didn't create.

meh too bad... I was looking for critique so I can go complain as a unsatisfied customer...

**chompy** · 10-29-2005, 11:11 PM

brucie, that's quite an array of sigs there...

as for orka, i really liked your old sig, but the new still has the same charm. must be the bordering. would be nice if the sig rules were relaxed... but that would be a suggestion, and we all know what happens to people who make suggestions

tofuman is bizarrely futuristic (nice use of plugin)

aztraph's is slightly distorted, but nice solid background.

and shinxzero uses a very VERY nice source artist for this.