Rate the signature and avatar above yours

[Shiryuu]

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

[kevinlmw]

kevinlmw
Avatar:
It's round and rather matches your sig,but I don't like monocolored pics,also maybe a border would be nice.
7/10
Signature:
The same problem as I mentioned in ava,just I like sigs which are colorfull,but overall feeling is nice,some kind of softness is there,but I would maybe add a blue thin border which would close whole sig.
8/10

understood!! i add a border
i use monocoloured because this character is taken from doujin*black&white* ... so far no luck on finding coloured oneT.T

yep initial D relates to what i did a few years back and Keisuke kinda reminds me of myself when i was 17

oic... no wonder. Nice to have something attracted to^.^

[doyrena]

yours nice

ive tried to make an animation with my sig, but it runs poorly with IE. i tried with firefox it runs perfectly. any idea why ?

[Kitee]

I changed my sig a little bit, since everyone is saying that my name is hard to read. Seriously, I see it perfectly, perhaps since I was looking at it for hours non-stop, I got used to it. ^^

kevinlmw:Nice signature. The 2 pictures blend in well and your trims are excellent as well. I think it would be better if the border is a solid one, not just a 2-D one colored background. Perhaps a variaties of color in the background, or make the edges of the background "embossed". I would also try to make the background colorful, to see if the effects good, that brings out the attention to the 2 girls. I'm not sure if you intended it, but when i first saw the girl's hand and the "HF [img]" quote, it seems as though she is holding it. But then, with the other 2 club quotes right below it, it doesn't have that effect as much. So maybe just keep one of the quotes and move the 2 to a different part of the sig, or make the 2 quotes at the bottom having a "duller" color. Overall, a nice sig. ^^

doyrena: Your sig is nice. Gif sigs are always creative. ^^ But the color and pixel quality are a bit lacking compared to jpeg ones. Your sig is quite smooth though. Oh, your sig is 172kb, you should change it quickly ^^ The max is 100kb.

[doyrena]

doyrena: Your sig is nice. Gif sigs are always creative. ^^ But the color and pixel quality are a bit lacking compared to jpeg ones. Your sig is quite smooth though. Oh, your sig is 172kb, you should change it quickly ^^ The max is 100kb.

really?? gotta make sumtin else. thanks for the reaction
i really like simple stuff. thats why my sig is not that colorful...

yours are nice. but for me, i would like to be simple...

[shinyo]

HAT - now it's perfect 10/10 [sig]

kevinlmw - nice pic, 8/10 both

doyrena - it catched my eye, but I'm not into it, 7/10

[doyrena]

i change the sig to meet the size limit...
i will make something else, but now i dont have a clue what sould i put in it...
feel free to comment, but i like simple stuff...

@Shinyo
that sig was nice!
too bad i can only use MS PAINT!

[Ponzu]

avatar - sig

june86 : 7/10 - 7/10
kevinlmw : 7/10 - 7/10
doyrena : 8/10 - 9/10
- Nice animation on the sig, it's so smooth.
HereAtThere : rated - 9/10
shinyo : 8/10 - 9.5/10
- I was going to use that in my sig too, but I chose this one instead. ^^

Damn Ponz, where do you get those pics ><

It's mostly from the same artist, Sakurazawa Izumi sensei.
The picture in my sig came from her artbook, La Cersaie.

[Fanin]

Ponzu
avatar: Using VIP privilege I see ^_^ 8/10
signature: the cuteness 9.5/10

Just couple more days of CNY celebration before taking my current sig off.

[kevinlmw]

i change the sig to meet the size limit...
i will make something else, but now i dont have a clue what sould i put in it...
feel free to comment, but i like simple stuff...

gif is very hard to make because of size limit
a simple three frame gif can pop from 44kb to 200kb.. plus the quality quite bad..





i suggest quit using animation and use jpeg or gif for transparent border only

by the way after hearing rakkam and HereAtThere comment i make a new version... is it nicer or worster?

[june86]

wow kevinlmw that new sig of yours looks much better than before it gots more color and it feels more lively i tell ya
so i give your new sig a 9