Rate the signature and avatar above yours

**Shiryuu** · 01-05-2005, 04:56 AM

Rules (similar to Asuki):
- You have to rate a sig
- you can rate multiple ones
- Don't just rate, comment (constructive criticism is preffered)
- Better if you have an image sig when you post
- rating system is out of 10.

**Mysterio006** · 02-04-2006, 11:41 PM

CherryMilkman: 9/10 - Great mix of images to make a symbol of HF

Ponzu: 10/10 - Masterpiece as always

**Kitee** · 02-05-2006, 02:41 PM

Ponzu: rated

Mysterio006: The picture content is nice. It's been a while that I've seen a signature with more than 1 character in it. With the stroke around the name, it catches a lot of attention. I don't think the color is quite fitting though. Also, the color quality seems to be a bit off. The border is nice and simple, which is the kind of borders I like. Overall, nice job. ^^

**KidSteel** · 02-05-2006, 03:15 PM

Ponzu: Cute picture, nicely arranged with a fitting, tasteful border.

Mysterio006: Well-chosen pic; the colour of the border of the text is a bit off, though, as HAT already noted.

HAT: I can't read the te... nah, just kidding, it's fine.

Just wondering if it wouldn't be better if the name is smaller and the "stay with me" larger than the other way around. Otherwise, fine Saber-pic, nicely blended with the background.

**Ether** · 02-05-2006, 04:58 PM

@kidsteel
AV: alrite, but kinda plain :/ 8/10
sig: nice blend of colors. the sun rays r even better: 9/10

**shinyo** · 02-05-2006, 11:07 PM

Ether - nice pic of XP-Chan, and a nice idea with the text xD, but you could make it better, visual stuff, boarders etc. 7/10; ava's cute 8/10

**Denamic** · 02-06-2006, 11:36 AM

I just made this sig. Just to see if I could. Note that it's kinda half-assed and sloppy, but it's the best I could do in half an hour. I'll need more inspiration before I start improving it..

**Kitee** · 02-07-2006, 03:44 AM

A new signature from me. ^^ It's a redone from my previous Arcueid signature, which is this. ^^

Ether:While rotating the signature, the picture has become pixelated. Adding a border would be nicer, and your name imo is too small. I suggest changing the quotes color because it's too contrasting to the rest of the siggie. Character-wise, there seems to be a "XP" on the left part of her hair. I'm not exactly what that is. I would also move the character a bit to the right so that all of her head is inside the signature. After fixing these minor things, the siggie would be much better. ^^

shinyo:Nice valentine theme. ^^ The color quality is a bit off. The border is nice and simple. Everything is done nicely. Fixing the picture quality would make it a better signature.

Denamic: Nice original idea. So far, I see 6 faces. ^^ It's nice just focusing on their eyes, but on the right side, have 2 faces on top of each other makes it really crowded and confusing. Also, the red scribbly lines looks a bit like crayon, which actually gives it a negative effect, since they appear random, and doesn't seem to enhance the signature in any way. There are other ways to make the faces of these characters look enigmous. As for the border, it's done really well. It's nice how the top right corner is actually the same as the bottom left corner, and vice versa. This signature as well, seems to be a little lacking in terms of color quality, most probably due to it being gif. Overall, it's a creative siggie, which gives a different feeling. ^^

**npdcb** · 02-07-2006, 08:24 AM

HAT
avatar: well it is Natsuki-chan after all, you got my full score

signature: the font colors match perfectly with the background, simple and neat, me like alot. the new version looks even better with double borders and quote

my new siggy: nothing too fancy, it's quite simple and meaningful for the upcoming holidays ^^
will work on a new ava, this one is too pixelate