Rate The Signature And Avatar Above Yours [Reloaded]

[BradWong]

icewirm:
ava: 6/10
sig: 7.8/10

comment: it looks good... but some people might think of other things

[outlaw02]

BradWong

Avatar: 8/10 (Add a simple border would do best)

Sig: 8/10 (Did not have that something to push me to give you a higher score)

[EchelonV]

9/9 above. No idea what they're from, but very nicely done. Both seem simple but just, good?

[Choo]

outlaw02

ava:8/10
sig:8/10

ur signature is cool. the effects

EchelonV
ava:7/10
sig:9/10

that sig is totally hot. =D

[maumastoks]

Choo:
ava: 7/10 - bad quality
sig: 8/10 - not bad but i dont like characters' quality

[Thingle]

^ 8/10. Left side empty

[cem]

6/10^ Thingle. Good. You have a nice cutout there of your main focus. That is also the thing that I would say you could experiment with,maybe? You kept color elements of the background and used a similar color scheme for the foreground. The median score comes from the busy background competing for the attention of the foreground. I would maybe try to experiment with a few things. Try bringing your main focus out more or toning down the background. You can change the values in "Image<adjustment<levels" and darken your main chars. Or the background and mess with that. I do like the blur effects on the foreground particle effects. Maybe add a outer glow or shadow to your character layer in photoshop? I think you have a great start and you understand complementing color schemes within your piece. Tighten it up and you could get a sweet sig with an unusual color scheme. Good luck.

Hears mine what do you guys think?

[msea]

6/10^ Thingle. Good. You have a nice cutout there of your main focus. That is also the thing that I would say you could experiment with,maybe? You kept color elements of the background and used a similar color scheme for the foreground. The median score comes from the busy background competing for the attention of the foreground. I would maybe try to experiment with a few things. Try bringing your main focus out more or toning down the background. You can change the values in "Image<adjustment<levels" and darken your main chars. Or the background and mess with that. I do like the blur effects on the foreground particle effects. Maybe add a outer glow or shadow to your character layer in photoshop? I think you have a great start and you understand complementing color schemes within your piece. Tighten it up and you could get a sweet sig with an unusual color scheme. Good luck.

Hears mine what do you guys think?

A little off topic: Please keep your comments brief and simple cem, thanks.

cem
ava: 7/10
Border-less, nice attempt though.
sig: 8/10 (current one) 8/10 (one you've specified)
Both are nice, but some of your works may need to tone down the color brightness a little.

[.tomi]

@msea
ava: 8/10 - that lack of bottom border was intentional? and the image is a bit too blurry.
sig: 10/10

[orisa]

Avatar: 10/10
Sig: 9/10 (Cute...^^)