Rate The Signature And Avatar Above Yours [Reloaded]

[Rick]

@vantoria
Avatar (7.5/10): Looks a bit too grainy for me. I mean, there are a little too many JPEG artifacts. Also, you could add some transparency to make it look a little more interesting. BTW, who's that chick?
Signature (8/10): The quality of this one is better but it could benefit of a border. Also, the color of your font isn't very appropriate, given the clothes the girl is wearing. I'd suggest you to use either yellow or blue to give it a better contrast to the rest of the picture.

@TenguSan
Avatar (8/10): Quality is decent but, like vantoria's, it could use a transparent background to make it look a little less plain.
Signature (10/10): Easiliy by far the best sig with a roach I've seen so far, period. Using the "server too busy" message was a very clever move. Very good editing the roach with a sweatdrop there. I actually feel like +repping you for this. It's that awesome.

[Ooame]

@Rick

Avatar 10/10: Your roach is super cute

Signature 8/10: Poison, Mako-chan, Bridget and jun. How much better could it get?

Why do i feel like my signature just doesn't fit in on this forum?

[vantoria]

@rick the reason why that's so is.. it's just a sketch for our site mascort.

Spoiler

Hmm yellow eh? i'll try to do it and decide if that's suitable or not. :S

- Rick's Sig nice transparent effect as it's was being done well porpotionally. i like it 9 out of 10.
- Ooame.. urrg lol? hahahha that was some nice... sig over there *stay away from ooame..
nevertheless. it was a good pictures and the font usage is good! a 10 out of 10! ^^

[105xSTRIKER]

@Ooame

Avatar: 9.0 It's a lot different from what I usually see, and it might say more about yourself than the average avatar. It has a nice vibe going with it.

Sig: Very nice. 9.5 I'd give it a 10 but It sorta seems out of place compared to the site Background.

[maumastoks]

105xSTRIKER:
ava: 1/10 - very low quality crop
sig: 2/10 - simple screenshot and resize from TTGL. TV-rip too (the time can be seen). You got 2 (not 1) for okay quality.
Sorry if I am harsh, but you did nothing. Nothing at all.

[scpyrus]

maumastoks:
Great avatar/signature combo!
10/10

[105xSTRIKER]

@ Scpryus

Avi: 9/ The colors are a little weird, but I like the general picture itself it even has your name :3

Sig: 10 I love the combination of all your clubs and even how it incorporates your name in there too, albeit a bit confusing, the general sig is awesome.

[Newbez]

Avatar: 6/10
Sig: 8/10 Love it, but I have no idea what anime that is ^__^

[maumastoks]

Newbez:
ava: 1/10 - a simple crop. I have that picture. Nothing else is done
sig: -/10 - no sig.
Resize the sig to 150 x 700 px or 100kb maximum. (read the forum rules)

[darkandshadow]

lol maumau is taking my job over! OH NOEZZ!!!
xD

Anyways, to the ratings!

@vantoria:

AVA: Good attempt, but the head is kind of squishy.
Would be interesting to see what you come up with as a
background for it. For now, a 5.5/10. A temp background
that matches would bring up the points plus a simple border.

SIG: Crop, but a decent quality image is used...It's
always good to use the biggest resolution images, as they
have higher DPI, which is excellent and prime "real estate"
to scale down and use within signatures.

You attempted to make your own, "side border", which is
always a plus...since borders are generally a 1px inside stroke.

The outer glow around the typography needs to fit in better
with the overall colour scheme you have going on, and
possibly a bit lighter than that, since you do want to make
the text stand out a bit. Also, use your "range" slider for it
to give it a softer feel to it, so it doesn't stick out like a
sore thumb.

Also, test drive some fonts for your usage on typography.
You'd be surprised on what works and what doesn't. What
you have here is ok, because of the simplicity of the sig
image itself, however, google "free fonts" and take a look
around for what's available. The bigger the stock pile of
fonts you have (that aren't ridiculous, like "joker"), the better
fit you'll have. Typography is just as important as the image
itself, as it can either make or break your signature image.

So for your signature, I'll give a 4/10. Not because of
anything "off" that I said, but rather you have plenty of room
here to improve on this image and to really make it shine.
(And for the fact that you've attempted some effort here).

@scpyrus:

AVA: Circle instead of a square...now you'll have to think
outside of the sphere =P (hey, box is 3D!) Not sure if the
blue ring you have around it really fits, even though technically
it is a complimentary colour to your scheme. Also, your text
looks really uncomfortable like that...especially with how thick
that stroke it around it. 4.3/10

SIG: lol...another miku sig .... *hides mine*
Anyways, a wavy grunge style...somewhat new take on the old
effect. I like how it's hinting so lightly on how it's blue on the
left then shoves it's way in towards the right; however, it's a
bit harsh in the middle. You may want to tone that down just a
bit.

The signature itself is surprisingly balanced, between the outer
glow on Miku, versus the bright spot where the contrast/brightness
has pretty much been maxed out (with some overlaying effects).
The red behind Miku to the right has an interesting twist, but
it seems too short. Widen that out a bit more towards the center.

Finally, you need some kind of container border...I would suggest
going gradient with that, to fit in more with the image as a whole.

Good job overall, just some minor detailing work and you're good
to go. 7.8/10

@Maus: I rated your ass long ago lmao...